Welcome to My Site

If this is your first visit, welcome! This site is devoted to my life experiences as a Filipino-American who immigrated from the Philippines to the United States in 1960. I came to the US as a graduate student when I was 26 years old. I am now in my mid-80's and thanks God for his blessings, I have four successful and professional children and six grandchildren here in the US. My wife and I had been enjoying the snow bird lifestyle between US and Philippines after my retirement from USFDA in 2002. Macrine(RIP),Me and my oldest son are the Intellectual migrants. Were were born in the Philippines, came to the US in 1960 and later became US citizens in 1972. Some of the photos and videos in this site, I do not own. However, I have no intention on infringing on your copyrights. Cheers!

Tuesday, January 20, 2026

Does Generative AI Weaken Critical Thinking?

Does Generative AI Weaken Critical Thinking? A Blogger’s Reflection After 15 Years Online

A couple of weeks ago,  I read an article by Larry Maguid asking a timely and unsettling question: Does generative AI weaken critical thinking?💚 It is a question many educators, parents, writers, and professionals are now wrestling with and one that resonates deeply with me as someone who has been blogging for more than 15 years.

When I started blogging in the late 2000s, the process was slow, deliberate, and sometimes uncomfortable. Writing meant wrestling with ideas, checking facts manually, revising drafts repeatedly, and occasionally publishing something imperfect. But that struggle was the point. It sharpened my thinking, clarified my values, and forced me to ask: What do I really believe, and why?

Thinking Before Tools

For most of my blogging life, technology assisted after thinking happened. Spellcheck corrected errors. Search engines helped confirm facts. But the core work forming an argument, telling a story, drawing connections remained stubbornly human.

Generative AI changes that sequence. Now, the tool can appear before the thinking. With a single prompt, a full article can appear in seconds, polished and confident. That efficiency is impressive but it also raises the concern Maguid highlights: If we outsource too much of the thinking, do we risk weakening the mental muscles that make thinking possible?

The Temptation of Convenience

As a long-time blogger, I understand the temptation. Writing regularly is demanding. Some days the words don’t come easily. AI can feel like a lifeline, an always-available assistant that never tires.

But I’ve also learned that the hardest posts to write are often the most meaningful. They come from reflection, uncertainty, lived experience, and sometimes even doubt. Those are not just writing challenges; they are thinking challenges. If AI removes that friction entirely, we may gain speed but lose depth.

AI as a Tool, Not a Substitute

From my perspective, the danger is not generative AI itself, but how passively we use it. Used thoughtfully, AI can enhance critical thinking rather than weaken it. It can:

  • Offer alternative viewpoints we might not have considered

  • Help organize complex ideas after we’ve formed them

  • Act as a sounding board, not a decision-maker

The key difference lies in authorship of thought. Am I using AI to clarify my thinking, or am I letting it do my thinking for me?

After 15 years of blogging, I know that my readers don’t come to my site for generic perfection. They come for perspective shaped by time, experience, and reflection, things no algorithm can genuinely replicate.

A New Responsibility for Writers

Generative AI forces writers and bloggers to take on a new responsibility: to be more intentional than ever about thinking first. The voice, judgment, and moral compass must remain human. Otherwise, we risk flooding the world with content that sounds smart but means very little.

Critical thinking has never been easy, and it was never meant to be. As bloggers, educators, and citizens, we should be cautious of any tool that promises to make thinking effortless. Effort, after all, is where understanding is born.

Final Thought

Generative AI is here to stay. The real question is not whether it weakens critical thinking, but whether we allow it to replace thinking instead of supporting it.

After more than a decade and a half of blogging, I remain convinced of this: tools may evolve, platforms may change, but the value of a well-thought-out idea earned through reflection and experience never goes out of date.

And that, perhaps, is the most critical thinking lesson of all.

Meanwhile, here's the AI Overview on the Above Topic: 

💚The main argument of the blog post "Does Generative AI Weaken Critical Thinking? A Blogger’s Reflection After 15 Years Online," likely authored by Larry Maguid
, is that the impact of generative AI on critical thinking is nuanced: it can act as a substitute for rigorous thought, but also as a tool to enhance it by offloading mundane tasks. 
The author draws on personal experience and existing research to present a balanced perspective on the issue, highlighting both potential pitfalls and benefits: 
  • Potential for Weakening: The primary concern is "cognitive offloading," where relying heavily on AI for complex reasoning can diminish a person's ability to solve problems independently. Studies suggest a negative correlation between high AI usage and critical thinking scores, as users may focus less on deep analytical work and more on merely refining AI outputs. This reliance is often driven by a desire for efficiency and convenience.
  • Potential for Enhancement: When used intentionally, AI can free up cognitive resources from lower-order tasks like data gathering or basic writing, allowing users to focus on higher-order critical thinking activities such as evaluation, synthesis of conflicting information, and strategic reflection.
  • Shifting the Nature of Thinking: The use of AI shifts the user's role from a primary content creator/problem solver to a "task steward" or "editor". Critical thinking is still required, but it involves new skills like effective prompt-writing, verifying AI-generated content for accuracy and bias, and integrating the results into a final, reliable product.
  • A Broader Trend: The author suggests that the decline in critical thinking is not solely caused by AI but is an acceleration of a longer-term trend, partly driven by the superficial engagement encouraged by social media and other digital technologies.
  • The Importance of Intentional Use: The ultimate impact depends on how individuals and educators choose to use the technology. Intentional strategies, such as structured assignments that require human evaluation and the cultivation of "slow cognition" habits like sustained reading, are necessary to harness AI's benefits while preserving human analytical skills. 

 My Reel of the Day: How to Remain Attractive

https://www.facebook.com/reel/876381391556622

Lastly, The top Five News of the Day

1) Trump’s Greenland Push and Rising Geopolitical Tensions

President Donald Trump is escalating controversy over his bid to take control of Greenland, linking it in private messages to not receiving the Nobel Peace Prize — fueling U.S.–Europe tensions, sparking diplomatic pushback and market jitters. 

2) Severe Geomagnetic Storm & Global Auroras

A strong G4-level geomagnetic storm hit Earth (from a coronal mass ejection), producing spectacular auroras visible far from the poles and impacting technology and satellite systems. 

3) Wall Street Near Three-Week Low Amid Greenland Dispute

U.S. markets slid as concerns about tariffs and geopolitical fallout from the Greenland tensions pressured stocks, dragging major indexes close to a three-week low. 

4) Controversial ICE Home Arrest Reported in Minnesota

An AP report says ICE agents forcibly entered a U.S. citizen’s home in Minnesota without a warrant, detaining him at gunpoint — part of broader disputes over immigration enforcement tactics. 

5) Anti-ICE Protester Disrupts Church Service

A Minnesota man accused of disrupting a church service to protest ICE also reportedly harassed congregants previously — adding to local tensions around immigration activism. 


No comments:

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...