A Father Looks Back on a Decision, a Football Record, and What We Know Today
I read an article today that made me stop and think about something that happened many years ago when my youngest son, David III, was in high school.
The article was about chronic traumatic encephalopathy, or CTE, a degenerative brain disease associated with repeated impacts to the head. The latest research on former NFL players is disturbing. Researchers recently reported that at least one in four former NFL players who died between 2016 and 2021 had CTE. The researchers examined donated brains and found CTE in 215 of 235 brains studied. They also emphasized that the 24.5% figure is a conservative estimate because not every former player donated a brain for examination.
As I read this, I immediately remembered my son David III.
"Over My Dead Body!"
When David III was in high school, he was a very athletic young man. Naturally, he became interested in playing football.
One day, the high school football coach approached my wife and asked for permission for David to play. My wife's immediate reaction was very clear:
"Over my dead body!"
She was afraid of exactly what we are talking about today, the possibility of a serious head injury.
At that time, we knew that football could be dangerous. We worried about concussions and broken bones. But our understanding of the long-term consequences of repeated blows to the head was nowhere near what it is today.
I understood my wife's concern. But I also knew our son.
David III was athletic, competitive and loved sports. I believed that with proper coaching, discipline and reasonable precautions, he should have the opportunity to play the sport he loved.
After some discussion, I eventually convinced my wife to allow him to play high school football. Looking back from 2026, I realize how difficult that decision really was.
The Decision Paid Off
David III did not merely play football. He excelled.
One of the most memorable moments of his high school football career came when he made an extraordinary running play. As I remember it, he ran approximately 90 feet with the football for a spectacular scoring run, helping him break his high school's record for the longest running-back scoring run.
For a father, moments like that are difficult to forget.
I can still remember the pride I felt watching my son demonstrate his athletic ability on the football field.
At that time, I was not thinking about CTE. I was thinking about a father watching his son succeed.
Finally, adding to our Peace of Mind, David III did not play College Football at UC Davis, in spite of what his High School Football coach said of him, as one of the best running back he had coached in his job as a high school Football Coach in the last couple of years.
What We Know Today
Today, we understand much more about the potential consequences of repeated head impacts.
CTE is different from an ordinary concussion. Researchers believe that repeated blows to the head, including impacts that may not produce obvious concussion symptoms can contribute to the development of CTE over time. Boston University researchers have also found that the cumulative force of head impacts matters, not simply the number of years an athlete plays.
And this is particularly important for young athletes.
Some research has found evidence of CTE even among young amateur athletes who died before age 30. That does not mean that every young football player will develop CTE. But it does tell us that repeated head impacts deserve serious attention beginning at the youth level.
This is where today's parents face a difficult question. Should my child play tackle football?
I don't believe there is one answer for every family.
Helmets Are Important-But They Are Not Magic
One thing particularly caught my attention in the article I read.
We often think of the football helmet as the ultimate protection against head injury. But a helmet cannot make football completely safe.
The CDC says that a properly fitted football helmet can help protect athletes from the most serious types of head and brain injuries, but helmets are not currently designed to prevent concussions.
That distinction is very important. A helmet can protect the skull.
It cannot completely prevent the brain from moving inside the skull when the head is suddenly struck.
And that is one reason why today's conversation about football safety is becoming less about simply designing a better helmet and more about reducing the number and severity of head impacts in the first place.
Boston University researchers have specifically emphasized that changes in rules, equipment and practice habits need to extend beyond the NFL to college, high school and youth football.
Would I Make the Same Decision Today?
This is the question I asked myself while reading the article.
Would I have allowed David III to play football if I had known then what I know today?
Honestly, I don't know. Perhaps I would have had a much longer conversation with the coach.
Perhaps I would have asked more questions about the team's safety practices, how much contact occurred during practice, how concussions were handled, and how the coaching staff monitored head injuries.
Perhaps I would have encouraged him to consider another sport.
But I also know something else.
Parents don't raise children with the benefit of hindsight.
We make decisions based on the knowledge available to us at the time.
My wife was trying to protect her son.
I was trying to give our son an opportunity to pursue something he loved.
Neither of us was wrong.
We were simply two parents trying to make the best decision we could.
Football Has Given Us Great Memories
I still enjoy watching football. I have been a San Francisco 49ers fan for many years, and I still appreciate the athleticism, strategy, teamwork and excitement of the game.
But loving football does not mean that we have to ignore its dangers.
In fact, perhaps the best way to preserve the sport is to make it safer.
The NFL and other football organizations have introduced rule changes, reduced certain contact practices and experimented with additional protective equipment. These are positive steps, but researchers continue to emphasize that reducing repetitive head impacts is critical.
And parents have an important role. We should ask questions. We should listen to our children.
We should make sure coaches take head injuries seriously.
We should never encourage a young athlete to "shake it off" and return to play after a suspected concussion.
And perhaps most importantly, we should remember that no football game is more important than the brain of a young person.
A Father's Memory
Fortunately, when I think about David III's football career, I don't think about CTE.
I think about a young man running down a football field with the ball in his hands.
I think about the excitement of watching him score. I think about the record he broke.
And I remember the conversation that started it all, when the coach asked his mother for permission and my wife responded:
"Over my dead body!" Eventually, she changed her mind. And I am glad she did.
But reading today's research has given me a different perspective.
We were lucky to have made our decision at a time when David played, succeeded and came home safely. Today, parents have more information than we had.
That information should not necessarily make them afraid of sports. Rather, it should make them better informed parents.
Perhaps that is the real lesson from the CTE controversy.
We don't have to choose between loving football and protecting our children.
We simply have to keep asking: How can we make the game we love safer for the next generation?
As a father and now a grandfather and great-grandfather, I believe that is a question worth asking. And perhaps my wife's original reaction wasn't so unreasonable after all.
"Over my dead body!"
Sometimes a mother's instinct deserves a second look.
Personal Note: CTE is a complex area of ongoing research. The recent "one in four" finding refers specifically to an estimated minimum prevalence among former NFL players who died during 2016–2021; it does not mean that one in four living NFL players currently has CTE. CTE can presently be definitively diagnosed only through examination of brain tissue after death.
AI Impressions on this Posting:
This is a powerful topic because it combines a very current medical concern with one of your own most memorable experiences as a father. I would make the post less about condemning football and more about the difficult decision parents face when a talented child wants to play a sport he loves.
The latest study is especially striking: researchers found CTE in 215 of 235 donated brains from former NFL players who died between 2016 and 2021, producing a conservative estimate that at least 24.5% about one in four of all former NFL players who died during that period had CTE. Because CTE can currently be confirmed only after death, the researchers emphasize that this is a minimum estimate, not a measurement of all living NFL players







